The Miami Dolphins have signed Jay Cutler to replace Ryan Tannehill. How will he do in a Dolphin uniform?
1. Super Bowl! They are going all the way, baby! This is setting up to be a great debut 30 for 30 for the 2028 television season.
2. Playoffs. Let's not overstate Tannehill's role in the Dolphins' playoff run last year. He was adequate, but no one is designing a statue to stand next to Marino. Cutler can be just as average.
3. Average. It is not like they reanimated Johnny Unitas. Everyone just pump the breaks on this guy being a Savior. If the Dolphins wanted that they could have signed Tebow.
4. Terrible. Any time you have to beg a guy to play for you (who is not known for giving a tinker's damn about what happens on the football field) it is not a good sign, no matter what bill of goods Adam Gase is trying to sell me.